Today: Oct 17 , 2019

YC Attorney Polk Weighs In on Supreme Court Decision
Featured

29 May 2019   Yavapai County Attorney Sheila Polk

STATEMENT OF YAVAPAI COUNTY ATTORNEY SHEILA POLK ON THE SUPREME COURT DECISION IN STATE V. JONES

The consequences of Tuesday's Arizona Supreme Court decision allowing the sale of high-potency drugs are troubling. The Court’s conclusion that the Arizona Medical Marijuana Act protects hashish (legally termed cannabis) is akin to finding that explosives produced from fertilizer are protected by laws allowing the sale of farm products.

Since 2010 when Arizona voters approved the use of medical marijuana, the potency and variety of products have soared. Smoked marijuana has potency levels averaging 5% to 15% THC, the mind-altering chemical in the marijuana plant. Manmade hashish products, derived from the concentrated resin from the marijuana plant, have potency levels of 70% to 90% THC.

This is the difference between Advil and morphine, and it’s why the Arizona Court of Appeals found that hashish is “susceptible to serious and extensive abuse.”

Sadly, the Supreme Court rejected the Arizona Appeals Court’s common-sense reasoning and its sound conclusion that hashish is a form of cannabis, which state law defines as distinct from the dried marijuana leaves.

Indeed, it’s a difference that dispensaries promote. Their websites advertise “mind-blowing shatter,” “Papa’s OG shatter,” and “mob moss” wax. These are medicines? 

Additionally, today’s ruling did not address the fact that any use of marijuana in Arizona continues to be illegal under federal law.  The United States Supreme Court has long recognized that Congress controls what is medicine in the U.S., and today the Arizona Supreme Court declined to resolve the continuing conflict between Arizona and federal law.

A plethora of recent peer-reviewed studies document the link between high potency THC and mental health, specifically psychosis. Today’s ruling by the Arizona Supreme Court gives a green light to an industry constantly seeking to market and sell more potent, and thus more addictive and dangerous, products. Communities across Arizona will suffer the consequences of this ruling long into the future.

BACKGROUND ON THE CASE

In March 2013, Rodney Jones was arrested and charged with possession of hashish (cannabis), a narcotic drug under Arizona law. At the time of his arrest, Mr. Jones was on probation for attempting to involve a minor in a drug offense, a class 3 felony. As part of the resolution of this case, Jones received favorable disposition and the dismissal of two criminal charges in another case. The trial court sentenced Mr. Jones to 2½ years in prison.

Mr. Jones appealed, arguing that, as a medical marijuana cardholder, he was entitled to use hashish, the resin extracted from the marijuana plant. The case was argued to the Arizona Court of Appeals. On June 26, 2018, the Court of Appeals ruled that use of hashish is not permitted by the Arizona Medical Marijuana Act. Mr. Jones then appealed this decision to the Arizona Supreme Court.

Read the unanimous AZ Supreme Court decision on State v. Jones here.